Profile last updated: February 20, 2026
1792 Bank Street, Suite 618
Orillia, ON K3L 1J0
1792 Bank Street, Suite 618, Orillia, ON K3L 1J0
Get Directions8 reviews
Jennifer Reid
Helpful staff
The staff at Carter & McCarthy Insurance were helpful when I needed to add a new driver to my auto policy. They found a way to keep the premium increase minimal.
Laura Kim
Local knowledge matters
Carter & McCarthy Insurance really understands the local insurance market in Orillia. Their connections with insurers helped me get coverage that bigger brokers couldn't.
Lucas Gagnon
Very knowledgeable team
Carter & McCarthy Insurance has a team of very knowledgeable brokers. They helped me understand the difference between various auto insurance coverages and what I actually need.
Anika Hamilton
Exceptional claims handling
When I had a water damage claim, Carter & McCarthy Insurance handled everything quickly and professionally. The claim was settled faster than I expected.
Isabelle Patel
Fair pricing
Carter & McCarthy Insurance offered fair pricing on our commercial insurance package. The broker understood our business needs. Would have liked a faster turnaround on the policy documents.
Noah Robertson
Mixed feelings
I had mixed feelings about Carter & McCarthy Insurance. The broker was friendly but seemed disorganized. Eventually got my auto insurance sorted but it took longer than expected.
Jasmine Wong
Slow and unresponsive
Carter & McCarthy Insurance was very slow in processing my business insurance application. Emails went unanswered for days. Eventually I went with another broker.
Robert Pelletier
Great experience!
I had an excellent experience with Carter & McCarthy Insurance. They found me the best auto insurance rate in Orillia and the whole process was seamless.
Verify this broker's licence: Check Carter & McCarthy Insurance's licensing status with the FSRA
Disclaimer: AtlasBrokers is a directory service. We do not sell, solicit, or negotiate insurance. Information on this page is for general reference only and should not be taken as financial or insurance advice.
Interested in getting a quote from Carter & McCarthy Insurance? Fill out the form below and they will get back to you.
Step 1 of 4: Type
Select the type of insurance you are looking for a quote on.
Claim this listing to update your information, respond to reviews, and more.
Claim This ListingTap a common question or write your own:
Estimate your insurance premiums based on your profile and coverage needs.
Get a quick estimate for your insurance costs across different coverage types.
Analyze your current coverage and find potential gaps in your insurance portfolio.
Discover how much you could save by comparing broker quotes.
Discover other insurance brokers that match your needs