Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceTenant InsuranceBusiness Insurance
Bay Insurance Solutions
Excellent
558 Elm Street, St. Catharines, ON P2J 9T9
Profile last updated: February 20, 2026
Est. 1989 10-25 team members
3.5
Bay Insurance Solutions is your neighbourhood insurance broker in St. Catharines, Ontario. We combine the personal touch of a local business with the buying power of access to dozens of insurance companies. This means better rates, better coverage, and better service for you.
Our brokerage handles all types of personal and commercial insurance, including auto, home, condo, tenant, business, and specialty coverages. We pride ourselves on making insurance simple and stress-free.
With over 37 years of experience in the insurance industry, we bring deep expertise and long-standing insurer relationships to every client interaction. Whether you're new to St. Catharines or have lived here your whole life, Bay Insurance Solutions is here to protect what matters most. Drop by our office or request a quote online.
Contact Information
Location
558 Elm Street
St. Catharines, ON P2J 9T9
Location Map
558 Elm Street, St. Catharines, ON P2J 9T9
Get DirectionsInsurance Lines
Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceTenant InsuranceBusiness Insurance
Specialties
Condo InsuranceProfessional Liability
Business Hours
SundayClosed
Monday09:00 - 18:00
Tuesday09:00 - 18:00
Wednesday09:00 - 18:00
Thursday09:00 - 18:00
Friday09:00 - 18:00
SaturdayClosed
Languages
English
Photos
Reviews
Write a Review
3.5
8 reviews
Sort by:
A
Andrew Campbell
Jan 2026
Perfect for small business
Bay Insurance Solutions set up our commercial liability and property insurance. They understood our industry and found coverage that actually fits our needs.
Was this helpful?
N
Nicole Martin
Dec 2025
Not what I expected
Based on reviews I expected more from Bay Insurance Solutions. The auto insurance rates they quoted were higher than what I found elsewhere. Didn't feel valued as a customer.
Was this helpful?
Y
Yuki Roy
May 2025
Solid broker
Bay Insurance Solutions is a solid insurance broker. They compared quotes from several companies for our auto insurance. Could improve their online portal though.
Was this helpful?
T
Thomas Pelletier
Dec 2024
Family business feel
Bay Insurance Solutions has that family business feel that you don't get from big insurance companies. They genuinely care about finding you the right coverage.
Was this helpful?
L
Linda Roy
Jun 2024
Good overall experience
Had a good experience with Bay Insurance Solutions. They found me a competitive rate for home insurance. Only minor issue was the paperwork took a bit longer than expected.
Was this helpful?
T
Thomas Gauthier
Jun 2024
Would recommend to anyone
The team at Bay Insurance Solutions in St. Catharines went above and beyond to help us. They shopped around and found us home insurance that was significantly cheaper.
Was this helpful?
J
Jacques O'Brien
May 2024
Amazing customer service
The staff at Bay Insurance Solutions are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. They answered all my questions about tenant insurance and found me a great policy.
Was this helpful?
R
Raj Leclerc
Apr 2024
Saved us money on auto insurance
Switched our auto insurance through Bay Insurance Solutions and saved a significant amount. The broker took the time to explain all the coverage options clearly.
Was this helpful?
Share Profile
Verify this broker's licence: Check Bay Insurance Solutions's licensing status with the FSRA
Disclaimer: AtlasBrokers is a directory service. We do not sell, solicit, or negotiate insurance. Information on this page is for general reference only and should not be taken as financial or insurance advice.
Request a Quote
Interested in getting a quote from Bay Insurance Solutions? Fill out the form below and they will get back to you.
Step 1 of 4: Type
What type of insurance do you need?
Select the type of insurance you are looking for a quote on.
Is this your brokerage?
Claim this listing to update your information, respond to reviews, and more.
Claim This ListingInsurance Partners
Intact InsuranceAviva CanadaWawanesa InsuranceThe Co-operatorsDesjardins InsuranceRSA InsuranceDefinity Insurance (Economical)Gore Mutual InsurancePembridge InsuranceCAA InsuranceTravelers CanadaNorthbridge InsuranceZurich CanadaWestland InsurancebelairdirectTD InsuranceSonnet InsurancePeace Hills Insurance