Auto InsuranceTenant Insurance
Bay Brokerage
Excellent
2186 Bay Street, Newmarket, ON L9E 6A5
Profile last updated: February 20, 2026
Est. 2015 5-10 team members
3.6
Bay Brokerage has built a reputation as one of Newmarket's most trusted insurance brokerages. Serving clients throughout Ontario, we leverage our relationships with numerous insurance carriers to deliver tailored insurance solutions for every stage of life and business.
From first-time drivers seeking affordable auto insurance to established businesses needing comprehensive commercial coverage, our team of licensed professionals is ready to help. We take the complexity out of insurance and make sure you understand exactly what you're covered for.
With 11 years of experience serving our community, we have built strong relationships with insurers and a deep understanding of our clients' needs. Join the hundreds of satisfied clients who have made Bay Brokerage their insurance broker of choice.
Contact Information
Location
2186 Bay Street
Newmarket, ON L9E 6A5
Location Map
2186 Bay Street, Newmarket, ON L9E 6A5
Get DirectionsInsurance Lines
Home InsuranceTenant InsuranceBusiness Insurance
Specialties
High-Risk DriversNew DriversSenior DriversConstruction InsuranceLife Insurance
Business Hours
SundayClosed
Monday08:00 - 16:30
Tuesday08:00 - 16:30
Wednesday08:00 - 16:30
Thursday08:00 - 16:30
Friday08:00 - 16:30
SaturdayClosed
Languages
EnglishFrench
Photos
Reviews
Write a Review
3.6
8 reviews
Sort by:
L
Lucas Belanger
Jun 2025
Good broker
Bay Brokerage took the time to review our existing policies and found gaps in our coverage. They fixed everything and the price was reasonable.
Was this helpful?
D
David Johnson
Mar 2025
Mixed feelings
I had mixed feelings about Bay Brokerage. The broker was friendly but seemed disorganized. Eventually got my auto insurance sorted but it took longer than expected.
Was this helpful?
C
Charlotte Lavoie
Jan 2025
Responsive and caring
When my basement flooded, Bay Brokerage was the first call I made. They walked me through the claims process and followed up regularly. A+ service.
Was this helpful?
F
Fatima Dubois
Sep 2024
Okay but not great
Used Bay Brokerage for tenant insurance. Price was average, service was fine. Nothing that really stood out compared to other brokers I've used.
Was this helpful?
M
Matthew Pelletier
Aug 2024
Excellent service
After a car accident, Bay Brokerage guided me through the entire claims process. I felt supported every step of the way. Cannot recommend them enough.
Was this helpful?
J
Jennifer Patel
Jul 2024
Made insurance easy
Insurance has always been confusing to me, but the team at Bay Brokerage explained everything in plain language. Got great tenant insurance coverage at a fair price.
Was this helpful?
B
Brandon Lefebvre
Jun 2024
Pretty good
Bay Brokerage helped us with our home insurance renewal. They found a slightly better rate. The process was straightforward, nothing exceptional but reliable.
Was this helpful?
H
Hassan Leclerc
Apr 2024
Great for bundling
Bay Brokerage bundled our home, auto, and umbrella policies together and saved us a ton. One broker handling everything makes life so much easier.
Was this helpful?
Share Profile
Verify this broker's licence: Check Bay Brokerage's licensing status with the FSRA
Disclaimer: AtlasBrokers is a directory service. We do not sell, solicit, or negotiate insurance. Information on this page is for general reference only and should not be taken as financial or insurance advice.
Request a Quote
Interested in getting a quote from Bay Brokerage? Fill out the form below and they will get back to you.
Step 1 of 4: Type
What type of insurance do you need?
Select the type of insurance you are looking for a quote on.
Is this your brokerage?
Claim this listing to update your information, respond to reviews, and more.
Claim This ListingInsurance Partners
Intact InsuranceAviva CanadaWawanesa InsuranceThe Co-operatorsDesjardins InsuranceRSA InsuranceDefinity Insurance (Economical)Gore Mutual InsurancePembridge InsuranceCAA InsuranceTravelers CanadaNorthbridge InsuranceZurich CanadaWestland InsurancebelairdirectTD InsuranceSonnet InsurancePeace Hills Insurance